Showing posts with label Jared Lee Loughner. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Jared Lee Loughner. Show all posts

Tuesday, July 12, 2011

Court: No forced medication for Giffords shooting suspect

PHOENIX — A federal appeals court Tuesday upheld its stay against forcibly medicating Tucson shooting suspect Jared Loughner and ordered the prosecution and defense attorneys to prepare for a hearing on the matter at the end of August.
At issue are a pair of U.S. Supreme Court rulings that specify when prisoners can be forced to take medications for psychiatric reasons. One requires only an administrative hearing if the inmate is a danger to himself and others; the other demands a court hearing if the inmate is being forcibly medicated to be restored to competency to stand trial.
Loughner was medicated, ostensibly for dangerousness, after a hearing in front of prison staff, but his attorneys alleged that the federal Bureau of Prisons was making an "end run" around the rules because its warden and psychological evaluators stated that they needed to treat the underlying psychiatric condition with the medication.
In the months after the January shootings, which killed six people and wounded 13, including Rep. Gabrielle Giffords, D-Ariz., the 22-year-old Loughner was diagnosed as a paranoid schizophrenic and sent to a federal facility in Springfield, Mo., for psychiatric restoration.
His attorneys immediately asked to be advised if he was to be medicated. Restoration to competency often involves medication, especially for schizophrenics.
Citing the two Supreme Court decisions, U.S. District Judge Larry Burns ruled that there would only be a hearing if the medication were for restoration, not for dangerousness. And in fact, unbeknownst to the court or the opposing lawyers, the Bureau of Prisons determined that Loughner was dangerous and began medicating him on June 22. Burns upheld the decision, however.
Loughner's attorneys, Judy Clarke and Reuben Camper Cahn, appealed to the U.S. 9th Circuit Court of Appeals, which stopped the forced medication pending review of the case. The attorneys debated the question in California on July 7. A three-judge panel ruled to keep the stay in place on Tuesday.
One sticking point is that the Supreme Court case that allows for a mere administrative hearing pertained to a prison inmate who had already been convicted. The second case, which required a court hearing, pertained to a "pre-trial detainee," like Loughner.
"Because Loughner had not been convicted of a crime, he is presumptively innocent and therefore entitled to greater constitutional protections than a convicted inmate," Tuesday's ruling said.
But, at this point, it narrowly applies to whether the preliminary injunction remains in place.
Now both sides must argue their cases before the appeals judges determine which type of hearing Loughner must undergo.

Thursday, July 7, 2011

Loughner attorneys seek halt to forced medication

Lawyers for the accused gunman charged with wounding Congresswoman Gabrielle Giffords in a deadly shooting rampage told a federal appeals court on Thursday that forcing him to take anti-psychotic drugs could cause him irreparable harm.
But 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals Chief Judge Alex Kozinski expressed skepticism during the hearing, which was held in Pasadena, a few miles from Los Angeles, saying of the defense team's argument, "I don't buy it."
The three-judge panel adjourned after 90 minutes without issuing a ruling and gave no indication how long it would deliberate before deciding whether to lift an earlier court order that temporarily bars prison officials from medicating Jared Loughner against his will.
Loughner did not attend the hearing. He remains held at a hospital for federal prisoners in Missouri after a lower-court judge in May declared him incompetent to stand trial on charges he killed six people and wounded 13 others, including Giffords, at a public event in Tucson, Arizona.
The 22-year-old college dropout, described by his own lawyers as "gravely mentally ill," has since been undergoing psychiatric evaluation to determine whether his ability to understand court proceedings against him can be restored.
U.S. District Judge Larry Burns denied an emergency petition filed by Loughner's attorneys in June seeking to bar prison officials from forcibly medicating him. Burns said he would defer to the judgment of doctors treating Loughner.
But the appeals court days ago ordered a halt to the involuntary medication while it reviewed the matter.
Federal prosecutor Christina Canabillis argued on Thursday that doctors were prompted to medicate Loughner against his will due to a number of outbursts in which he threw chairs in his cell and spat at one of his own attorneys. Such behavior clearly poses a danger to the medical personnel trying to determine his competency, she said.
But defense lawyer Reuben Cahn argued that forcing anti-psychotic drugs on Loughner amounted to a "serious invasion on personal liberty" resulting in "irreparable damage." Prison officials coerced Loughner by threatening to strap him down and inject him if he refused to take pills prescribed by his doctors, Cahn said.
"Nothing can reverse the injury done to him," Cahn said.
Kozinski expressed doubt about permanent harm, comparing the situation to a person taking pain medication.
Loughner is accused of opening fire on Giffords and a crowd of bystanders outside a Tucson supermarket on January 8. Six victims were killed and 13 were wounded, including Giffords, who is still recovering from a gunshot to the head.
He pleaded not guilty in March to 49 charges stemming from the shooting rampage at the "Congress on Your Corner" event, including multiple counts of first-degree murder.
At the competency hearing in May, Judge Burns cited the conclusions of two medical experts that Loughner suffers from schizophrenia, disordered thinking and delusions.

Wednesday, May 25, 2011

Giffords shooting suspect deemed incompetent to stand trial

A federal judge ruled Wednesday that Jared Lee Loughner was incompetent to stand trial, all but ending, for now, legal proceedings in the January shooting that killed six people and wounded 13 others, including Arizona Democratic Rep. Gabrielle Giffords. After studying reports from two mental health experts who examined the 22-year-old defendant, Judge Larry A.
Burns ordered that Loughner be kept in custody and stopped any federal trial unless Loughner were to be rehabilitated later, would be able to understand the charges against him and assist in his own defense. The charges carry the potential of the death penalty.


The ruling also appears to put on hold any state trial against Loughner.
He was ordered removed from the courtroom after an outburst. Reporters heard him shout: "She died in front of me," "Thank you for the freak show" and, "You're treasonous." A staff psychologist at the U.S. Medical Center for Federal Prisoners in Springfield, Mo., and a forensic psychiatrist in San Diego both agreed that Loughner at this time is unfit mentally to stand trial. Calling the shuttle: For students at Mesa Verde Elementary School in Tucson, it was an unusual time to come to school: Sunday night. But it was an even more unusual school activity: making a long distance call 216 miles straight up to the space shuttle Endeavour. The educational event was set up by Endeavour commander Mark Kelly, husband of Rep. Gabrielle Giffords, who was wounded in the Jan. 8 shootings that killed six people, including 9-year-old Christina-Taylor Green. Christina-Taylor went to Mesa Verde.

Saturday, May 21, 2011

Feds alerted to Gabrielle Giffords shooter three months before Tucson massacre

The Tucson community college that booted attempted assassin Jared Lee Loughner asked federal firearms agents to check his background three months before his shooting rampage.
Hundreds of emails released by Pima Community College show school officials investigated the troubled young man in the months before he shot Rep. Gabrielle Giffords and 17 others in January, killing six.
They eventually suspended him, but during the weeks after the bloodbath administrators wondered if they did enough.

The emails depict a student with serious emotional problems whose strange behavior upset those around him.
In February 2010, a student emailed a writing teacher that Loughner put a knife on his desk. The teacher forwarded the complaint to an administrator and said he'd heard a similar complaint from another student.
"I think we ought to have another conversation with Jared to try to get to the bottom of this, and really at this point, I'd like to do everything that we can to have him removed from the class," teacher Steven Salmoni wrote.
"I think his presence alone is interfering with the kind of environment that I'm trying to foster in this course."
Loughner was in trouble again four months later after a math teacher said in an email that he appeared to be on drugs. School counselor DeLisa Siddall met with him the next day.
According to emails, Loughner told Siddall he was being "scammed" by his math teacher.
"He said, 'My instructor said he called a number 6 and said I call it 18.' He also asked the instructor to explain, 'How can you deny math instead of accept it?'" Siddall wrote.
Siddall told the teacher that Loughner would return to class but stop asking questions. The next day, the teacher said Loughner returned to class and was laughing inappropriately and staring at classmates with an "evil" smile.
That led campus police to recommend Dean Patricia Houston expel him, but Houston said in an email it was premature.
"It is a matter of balancing the disruptive student's right to due process with the rights of the other students in the class," Houston wrote.
More disruptions eventually prompted administrators to suspend Loughner from school. As they did, campus cops contacted the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives to look into him as a "person of interest."
Less than two weeks after the shooting, the school's director of contracts and risk management wrote an email to administrators saying the college should have done more.
"Arizona has one of the most lenient criteria for a commitment procedure which, having read the police reports, should have been initiated," Dworschak wrote. "You don't dump them."

Tuesday, March 22, 2011

Mental exam for Giffords shooting suspect Loughner

A judge has ordered the man charged in the January shooting rampage in Arizona to undergo a mental evaluation to see if he is competent to stand trial.
The evaluation at a specialist facility in Missouri will be filmed.
It will not examine whether Jared Lee Loughner, 22, was sane at the time of the shooting in Tucson, which left six people dead and 13 injured, including Congresswoman Gabrielle Giffords.
Mr Loughner has pleaded not guilty to 49 charges stemming from the attack.
They include killing US District Judge John Roll and Mrs Giffords' aide, Gabe Zimmerman, and attempting to kill Mrs Giffords and two other aides.
Mr Loughner is also charged with causing the deaths of four others, including a nine-year-old girl, who were not federal employees, causing injury and death to participants at a "federally provided activity", and using a gun in a crime of violence.
In total, 14 of the charges are punishable by death. However, prosecutors have not yet said if they will pursue the maximum penalty.
Mental disease or defect
Mr Loughner will travel to the Bureau of Prisons facility in Springfield, Missouri, because prosecutors had argued that his evaluation should take place at a medical referral centre that provided forensic services and had increased resources.
His lawyers had wanted the exam to be done by an expert at a prison in Arizona, as it might disrupt their relationship with him. They also wanted assurances that it would be limited to ascertaining whether their client was competent to stand trial, not whether he was sane on 8 January.
Judge Larry Burns ruled against the defence's first request, saying the relocation to Springfield was "unavoidable", but agreed with the second.
"The question at issue is whether the defendant is presently suffering from a mental disease or defect rendering him mentally incompetent to the extent that he is unable to understand the nature and consequences of the proceedings against him, or to assist properly in his defence."
The judge ordered that the exam be conducted no later than 29 April, and said he expected a report to be submitted by 11 May.

Monday, March 7, 2011

Three slain in Tucson rampage were shot in head



Three of the six people killed in the Jan. 8 rampage that injured Rep. Gabrielle Giffords (D-Ariz.) died of gunshot wounds to the head, according to autopsy records released Monday.
Prosecutors had asked U.S. District Judge Larry Burns to bar the release of the records, saying that news stories about them could "taint the jury pool" and jeopardize a fair trial.
Prosecutors also told Burns that the families of five of the victims requested that the autopsy results be kept private. But the judge rejected the prosecutors' request last week and allowed their release by the Pima County Medical Examiner's Office.
The records show that Giffords aide Gabriel Zimmerman and two victims in their 70s - Phyllis Schneck and Dorwan Stoddard- died of gunshots to the head. Nine-year-old Christina Taylor Green was killed by a gunshot wound to her torso, with the bullet striking her aorta, kidney, stomach and small intestine.
U.S. District Court John M. Roll was shot in the lower back, with a bullet perforating his aorta, according to the autopsy report. Dorothy Morris, also in her 70s, was killed by a bullet that pierced her heart.
Nineteen people, including Giffords, were injured in the attack outside a Tucson grocery store. The suspect in the shootings, Jared Lee Loughner, has been charged with 49 federal counts.
Loughner is scheduled to be arraigned Wednesday in Tucson.
Chief Medical Examiner Bruce O. Parks said in a statement Monday afternoon that his office would not discuss the reports.